ISSN (Online): 2321-3418
server-injected
Engineering and Computer Science
Open Access

A Concept of Housing and Settlements based Sustainable Spatial Articulation for Indonesian Cities

DOI: 10.18535/ijsrm/v10i10.ec01· Pages: 928-939· Vol. 10, No. 10, (2022)· Published: October 4, 2022
PDF
Views: 489 PDF downloads: 205

Abstract

This article aimed at introduce and offer a concept of  'spatial articulation' that sustainable in developing the ideal urban housings and settlements in Indonesia, 'Spatial Articulation' is a concept or a theory developed from the theory of 'Articulation of Mode of Production'—A  theory in the realm of macro sociology that offers the assumption that social formations on the periphery (developing countries) are mastered, at least, by two modes of production, capitalist mode of production and pre-capitalist mode of production—where one of them dominated the other(s). In addition, Urban Critical theories and Henri Lefebrve's concept on Production of ​​Space also contributed to the birth of the Theory of Urban Spatial Articulation. The assumption is that when the capitalists sector reproduces the "abstract (that planned) spaces”, then sooner or later, the pre-capitalist sector will do the articulation by reproducing the "differential (that unplanned) space” in or around the "abstract spaces"  that reproduced by the capitalist sector.

Keywords

Spatial articulationCapitalists mode of productionPre-capitalists mode of productionSocial formationReproduction of SpaceAbstract SpaceDifferential spaceSocial formation

References

  1. H. Setiono—Rural-Urban Circular Migration and Development: The Case of Building Construstion Labourers in Ujung Pandang, Indonesia. Master Thesis. Departement of Urban and Regional Planning. University of Sydney, 1993Google Scholar ↗
  2. L.R. Bromley—Organization, Arrangement and Entrepreneurship of the Informal Sector in the City: Street Traders in Colombia”, in Urbanization, Unemployment and the Informal Sector in the City, C. Manning, C. and T.N. Effendy (eds). Jakarta: PT. Gramedia. 1998, pp 228-50Google Scholar ↗
  3. T.S.S. Eisenring—Rural-Urban Circular Migration: Study of Trishaw Riders based at the Street of Rappocini Raya in Ujung Pandang. Master Thesis. Study Program of Urban Management, Postgraduate Program, Hasanuddin University, Makassar, 1996.Google Scholar ↗
  4. T.S.S. Eisenring—Toward the Theory of Urban Spatial Articulation (Study Results at two Commercial Centers in Makassar City, Indonesia). In International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology ISSN No:-2456-2165. Volume 3, Issue 5, May – 2018, pp 147-54.Google Scholar ↗
  5. L.I. Eisenring—Social Formation and Urban Spatial Articulation (A Study at the Locality of Somba Opu Street Shopping Center in Makassar City. Master Thesis, Study Program of Master of Urban and Regional Planning. Postgraduate Program, Bosowa University, Makassar. 2015Google Scholar ↗
  6. T.S.S. Eisenring—Housing and Urban Settlements Based on Sustainable Spatial Articulation (Towards the Ideal Urban Housing and Settlement Concept in Indonesia). Paper presented at the National Seminar on "Looking For The Ideal Concept of Housing and Settlements in Urban". Imperial Aryaduta Hotel, Makassar, Ministery of PUPR. 09th Desember 2016.Google Scholar ↗
  7. M. Nawir, M., 2016. Urban Space Mastery and Urban Social Coexistence (Case Study of "Daya" Wholesale Market of Makassar). PhD Disertation. Study Program of Sociology. Postgraduate Program, Makassar State UniversityGoogle Scholar ↗
  8. T.S.S. Eisenring, & B. Surya—Articulation of Urban Spatial: A Conceptual Approach Toward Sustainable Urban Spatial Planning for ‘Third World’ Cities, Procedings: International Conference: “Local Wisdom in Global Era”. Yogyakarta, January 22-22, 2011, ISBN 979813996-8. 2011Google Scholar ↗
  9. C.T.Lakshmanan—Evolution Evolution of Human Settlement. [Online] Available: http://www.slideshare.net/ctlachu/evolution-of-human-settlements. (November 17, 2016). 2016Google Scholar ↗
  10. C. Chase-Dunn, and A. Jorgenson—Settlement Systems: Past and Present”. [Online]. Available: http:// www.irows. ucr.edu/research/ citemp/setsys/setsys.htm. (November 17, 2016). 2016Google Scholar ↗
  11. Forbes, D. K.—Geography of Underdevelopment: A Critical Survey. Jakarta: LP3ES. 1979Google Scholar ↗
  12. Burgess, E. W.—The Growth of The City: An Introduction to a Research Project, in The City, R.E., Park, E. W. Burgess and R.D. McKenzie (eds.) ISBN: 0-226-64611-4. Chicago & London: The University Of Chicago Press. 1925Google Scholar ↗
  13. Eni and Tri. 2014—Structure of City Space, SS Belajar. [Online]. Available: http://ssbelajar.blogspot.com/2012/12/struktur-ruang-kota. html (April 6, 2014). 2014Google Scholar ↗
  14. H. Hoyt—The Structure and Growth of Residential Neighbourhoods in American Cities. Washington: Federal Housing Administration. 1939.Google Scholar ↗
  15. S. Mehta—Theories and Concepts of town planning. In SlideShare. [Online]. Available: https://www.slideshare.net/shonasrish/theories-and-concepts-of-town-planning (May 18, 2018). 2011.Google Scholar ↗
  16. C.D. Harris and E.L. Ullman—Nature of Cities.. In Cities and Society, P. K.Hatt and A. J. Reiss Jr, (eds). pp 237-47. [Online]: Available: http://www.unz. org/Pub/HattPaul-1951-00237. (April 19, 2014). 1945/1951Google Scholar ↗
  17. H. S. Yunus—Theory and Model of Spatial Structure of City. Yogyakarta: Gajah Mada University. 1994Google Scholar ↗
  18. Ecumene—Five Urban Model. In SlideShare. [Online]. Available: https://www.slideshare. net/ecumene/5-urban-models (May 17, 2018) 2009Google Scholar ↗
  19. Briney, A.—Latin American City Structure Model: Unique City Structure In Latin America Due To Their Colonial Past. In About.Com. [Online]. Available: http:// Geography. About.Com/Od/Urbaneconomic geography/A/Latin-American-City-Structure-Model.Htm (November 17, 2016). 2014Google Scholar ↗
  20. Rizaldy, 2012. Model Spatial Klasik (Struktur Ruang) Sebuah Kota. In Rizaldy Berbagi Data.[Online]. Available: (http://rizaldyberbagidata. blogspot. com/2012/07/ model-spatial-klasik-struktur-ruang.html.(April 9, 2014). 2012Google Scholar ↗
  21. T. McGee—The Southeast Asian City. New York: Praeger. 1967Google Scholar ↗
  22. L.Ford—A Model of the Indonesian City Structure. In Geographical Review 83(2) 374–96. 1993Google Scholar ↗
  23. M. Pacione—Urban geography: a global perspective—2nd. ISBN 0-203-02352-8 Master e-book ISBN. New York: Routledge 270 Madison Ave. 2005Google Scholar ↗
  24. Marcuse, P.—“From Critical Urban Theory”. In City Volume 13, 2009 – Issue 2-3: Cities for People, not for Profit, 2009. pp 185-97.Google Scholar ↗
  25. N. Brenner—What is Critical Urban Theory”. In City For People Not For Profit: Critical Urban Theory and The Right the City, N Brenner, P. Marcuse; and M. Mayer (eds).. New York & London: Rautledge, Taylor & Francis Group. 2009Google Scholar ↗
  26. H. Lefebvre—La Produktion de L’espace. Edition Anthoropos. 1981Google Scholar ↗
  27. H. Lefebvre—Writing on Cities. Blacwell Publisher. 1996Google Scholar ↗
  28. P. P. Rey—The Liniage Mode of Production. In Critique of Anthropology , 3. Hal. 27-79. 1975Google Scholar ↗
  29. C. Meillassoux—From Reproduction to Production. In Economic and Society 1, 1. 1972., pp 93-105.Google Scholar ↗
  30. K. Marx—A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy. New York: International Publishers. 1859/1970Google Scholar ↗
  31. Encyclopedia of Marxism—MIA. In Glossary of Terms. [Online]. Available: https://www. marxists.org/encyclopedia/terms/m/o.htm (November 23, 2016). 2008Google Scholar ↗
  32. Enciclopedia of Marxism—Mode of Life; Mode of Production”. Enciclopedia of Marxixm: Glosary of Term. [Online]. Avalilable: https://www.marxists.org/glossary/terms//m/o.htm#mode-production. (February 19, 2016). 2016Google Scholar ↗
  33. J. Taylor—Precapitalism modes of production. In Critique in Anthropology, 4, 5.: 127-55. 1975Google Scholar ↗
  34. J. Taylor—Precapitalism modes of production (Part 2)”. In Critique in Anthropology, 6,2.: 56-69. 1976Google Scholar ↗
  35. J. Taylor—Pre-capitalist mode of production. In Critique of Anthropology , 6, 2. Hal. 5-23. 1979Google Scholar ↗
  36. B. Surya—Social Change at Local Community of Tanjung Bunga Area of Makassar City, PhD Desertation. Study Program of Sociology. Postgraduate Program, Makassar State University. 2010Google Scholar ↗
  37. T.S.S. Eisenring— Splashes Ideas and Empirical Experiences toward Architectural Sociology ISBN 978-979-15597-9-9. Makassar: Fahmis Pustaka. 2013Google Scholar ↗
  38. D. J. Widiantono— Sustainable Cities: City Building Without Injury. In Participatory design. [Online]. Available: http://buletin.penataanruang. net/upload/data_artikel/Kota.Berkelanjutan.Kota.Tanpa;Luka-DR.Ir. Doni.J.Widiyantono.M.Eng.Sc.Pdf. (May 29, 2010). 2010.Google Scholar ↗
  39. T. Jayalangkara, and Patriawan—Upaya Meniup Bara Menjadi Api: Catatan Awal Tentang Perjuangan Warga Bulogading”. [Online]. Available: https://perhimpunanmer deka.wordpress.com/2015/08/26/ upaya-meniup-bara-menjadi-api/). (November 21, 2016). 2015Google Scholar ↗
  40. B.K. O’Malie—Is Indonesia a "Third World" Country ? - Whose on First ?. [Online]. Available: http://brianindonesiaexpat. blogspot.co.id/ 010/11/is-indonesia-third-world-country-whose.html. (November 22, 2016). 2010.Google Scholar ↗
  41. C. Pelipurlara— Setup of River Basin Areas Becomes More Ecological, Cases of the River of "Code”. [Online]. Available: http://infonetizen. com/article/penataan-kawasan-bantaran-sungai-menjadi-lebih-ekologis-kasus-bantaran-sungai-code#sthash.v8niF7nD.dpuf. (November 22, 2016). 2016Google Scholar ↗
  42. S. Adiningsih—Globalisasi Ekonomi dan Negara Sedang Berkembang” In Indonesian Journal for Sustainable Future Vol. 1 No. 1 Juli 2005. pp. 29-34. 2005Google Scholar ↗
  43. Eisenring, T.S.S., 2006. ” Urban Efficiency and Land Use Issues for Urban Poor Groups. In Prospek 38, June 2006. Pp 210-6. 2006.Google Scholar ↗
  44. E.S. Mills—Urban Efficiency, Productivity, and Economic Development. In Proceedings of The World Bank : Annual Confrence on Development Economic, pp. 121-35. The World bank. 1991Google Scholar ↗
  45. P. McAuslan— Urban Land and the protection of the people. Jakarta: Gramedia. 1986Google Scholar ↗
Author details
Hidayat Marmin
Lecturer of Architectural Sociology at the Department of Architecture Faculty of Engineering, Pepabri University Makassar, Indonesia
✉ Corresponding Author
👤 View Profile →